Home » Publications »
The DOL Fiduciary Process Agreement for ESOP Transactions
An NCEO Issue Brief
by Theodore M. Becker, Bradford P. Campbell, and Julie A. Govreau
This is provided as a PDF, with no shipping charges. It also is available in a print version (for which shipping charges apply).
$15.00 for NCEO members; $25.00 for nonmembers
A 20% quantity discount will be applied if you are a member (or join now) and order 10 or more of this publication. If you need to order more than the maximum number in the drop-down list below, change the quantity once you have added it to your shopping cart.
This ebook may not be resold or given away to others. If you would like to share this book with another person, please purchase an additional copy for each recipient. For example, if you want a copy for yourself and two colleagues, choose the quantity 3, add it to your cart, and check out. You will then download one copy that you can also provide to your two colleagues. Thank you for respecting our rights as an independent publisher.
NCEO members who supply their members area username and password during checkout can download digital publications like this one immediately after submitting an online order. Others will immediately receive a download link that will become live within one business day.
This issue brief, coauthored by attorneys involved in negotiating the agreement, assists readers in interpreting the agreement by putting its provisions in context. For each section of the agreement, the authors quote the agreement's language; point, where appropriate, to preexisting guidance containing policies and procedures embodied in the agreement; and provide commentary, based on their involvement in negotiating the agreement with the DOL, on how its provisions are intended to operate. Appendices provide a convenient checklist for implementing the agreement as well as the full text of the agreement itself.
Format: PDF, 26 pages
Dimensions: 8.5 x 11 inches
Edition: 1st (October 2014)
Status: Available for electronic delivery
Usage Rights for NCEO Digital Publications
When you download an NCEO digital publication that you purchase or subscribe to (or that someone purchases or sponsors for you), you may copy it to any computer or other electronic device you personally use, and you may print it for your own use. However, you may not share it with others unless you purchase a license to do so or buy a copy for each person.
Fiduciary Process Agreement: Preamble
Section A: Selection and Use of Valuation Advisor—General
Section B: Selection of Valuation Advisor—Conflicts of Interest
Section C: Selection of Valuation Advisor—Process
Section D: Oversight of Valuation Advisor—Required Analysis
Section E: Financial Statements
Section F: Fiduciary Review Process—General
Section G: Fiduciary Review Process—Documentation of Valuation Analysis
Section H: Fiduciary Review Process—Reliance on Valuation Report
Section I: Preservation of Documents
Section J: Fair Market Value
Section K: Consideration of Claw-Back
Section L: Other Professionals
Section M (Untitled)
Appendix 1: Fiduciary Process Checklist
Appendix 2: Text of the Fiduciary Process Agreement
About the Authors
About the NCEO
Section F: Fiduciary Review Process—General (footnotes omitted)In connection with any transaction involving the purchase or sale of employer securities that are not publicly traded, the Trustee agrees to do the following:
- Take reasonable steps necessary to determine the prudence of relying on the ESOP sponsor's financial statements provided to the valuation advisor, as set out more fully in paragraph E above;
- Critically assess the reasonableness of any projections (particularly management projections), and if the valuation report does not document in writing the reasonableness of such projections to the Trustee's satisfaction, the Trustee will prepare supplemental documentation explaining why and to what extent the projections are or are not reasonable;
- Document in writing its bases for concluding that the information supplied to the valuation advisor, whether directly from the ESOP sponsor or otherwise, was current, complete, and accurate.
Although an independent assessment of value is not a complete defense to a charge of imprudence, it is "evidence of a thorough investigation" and also is evidence of good faith.
A trustee may prudently rely on its experts' analysis and opinions, where the trustee (1) "investigate[d] the expert's qualifications," (2) "provide[d] the expert with complete and accurate information" and (3) "ma[de] certain that reliance on the expert's advice is reasonably justified under the circumstances."
Section F of the Fiduciary Process Agreement sets forth the general requirements for the Fiduciary Review Process, while Sections G and H provide requirements for documentation. Such documentation will provide a solid record of the prudent process that the trustee undertook in approving a transaction. Documentation of the process may be contained within the valuation report, fiduciary committee meeting minutes, due diligence memoranda, or a transaction memorandum.
It is not enough for the trustee to rely solely on the opinion of its valuation advisor in assessing whether projections are reasonable. If the valuation advisor does not document the reasonableness of management projections, then the trustee should do so. The trustee should also document its basis or evidence for concluding that information supplied to the valuation advisor was current, complete, and accurate.