Are you an NCEO member? Learn more or sign up now.

Home » Columns »

The Employee Ownership Update

Corey Rosen

November 2, 2009

(Corey Rosen)

Defined Contribution Plan Limits to Remain Unchanged in 2010

Because inflation has grown at a negative rate over the last year, the IRS has announced there will be no changes in the various limits for contributions, distributions, defining highly compensated employees, and employee deferrals for 2010.

House Concurrent Resolution Expressing Continued Support for ESOPs Introduced

Congressman Maurice Hinchey (D-NY) and six Republican cosponsors have introduced House Concurrent Resolution 204, expressing continued support for employee stock ownership plans (ESOPs). The resolution cites the strong performance history of ESOPs as reason for Congress to continue its support for the plans. The cosponsors are Congressman Eric Cantor (R-VA), Congressman Howard Coble (R-NC), Congressman Walter B. Jones, Jr. (R-NC), Congressman Dana Rohrabacher (R-CA), Congressman Edward R. Royce (R-CA), Congressman Mark E. Souder (R-IN).

Concurrent resolutions have no force of law but can be useful tools in showing support for a concept. The text of the resolution can be found at (search for H. Con. Res. 204).

NCEO Board Nominations Now Open

The NCEO will hold its annual election for board members in January. We accept only self-nominations. Board members serve a three-year term at their own expense. The board meets in person during the afternoon and evening preceding the annual conference and the morning of the conference. In addition, board members serve on committees that help create projects, develop material for books and meetings, promote membership, and work with staff on finding funding for research projects. We seek members who will take an active role in NCEO affairs.

Nominees must be members in good standing. Send a 100-word statement to Corey Rosen at that we can use in the election ballot no later than December 15.

SARs or Options in Closely Held Companies?

If you have a closely held company, which is better, stock appreciation rights (SARs) or stock options? Options are still the most popular choice, but consider some downsides: when someone exercises an option, they have to pay after-tax cash for the shares. Then, unless there is a simultaneous liquidity event, they have to hold onto the shares until a liquidity event occurs at some uncertain future date. They may also have to pay ordinary income taxes on the spread between the grant and strike price (on nonqualified options) or alternative minimum tax (in incentive options).

From the owners' standpoint, this seems like a great reward. Employees will have the chance to cash in big when a liquidity event (typically a sale of the company or, more rarely, an IPO) happens. From the employee's standpoint, there is current pain and uncertain future gain. We know from behavioral economics that most people overvalue costs and risks relative to potential gains, so they may see the award as more punishment than reward. Moreover, some employees may not see themselves staying until a liquidity event occurs, or will be uncertain whether one ever will occur. What will they do with their shares if the event doesn't happen or they leave before it? Will the company buy their shares at current value or just tell them to hold on to them? This uncertainty further erodes the value of the award.

Of course, the company could just buy the shares immediately. But in that case, why bother with the shares at all? A stock appreciation right accomplishes the same thing and leaves the employee with a net settlement, after taxes, of cash or shares. No pain, all gain.

There are two potential drawbacks, however. First, the company has to have resources to pay for the SAR at exercise (at the very least, to pay the taxes due if just shares are issued, but all the costs is cash is issued). Second, the employee typically has less flexibility in choosing when to exercise after vesting occurs, although it is possible to structure a deferral election into the process.

Author biography and other columns in this series

PrintEmail this page

PrintPrinter-friendly version