The Employee Ownership Update
February 1, 2011
New Data on ESOP Repurchase ObligationsA new NCEO survey of over 420 ESOP companies on how they handle their repurchase obligations found that the most commonly used method of funding current-year ESOP distributions is cash from company operations. Fifty-eight percent of respondents used cash from operations for funding distributions in the most recent plan year, and 43% exclusively used cash from operations. The next most common sources of repurchases were annual cash contributions to the ESOP (used by 30% of respondents) and cash in the ESOP from prior year contributions (used by 27%). Six percent used corporate sinking funds, and the other funding sources (corporate-owned life insurance, new ESOP debt, and purchases by management) were used by no more than 3% of respondents.
About three-quarters of the companies immediately or after some delay move shares bought from former employees back into the ESOP. Most companies make distributions in lump sums, followed closely by companies that pay in installments for larger balances and lump sums for smaller balances. Two-thirds of respondents giving a valid response said that their company's valuation firm considers repurchase obligation in appraising the company's stock, a dramatically higher percentage than in past surveys. Eighty-four percent of respondents said that they intend their ESOPs to be permanent.
A report on the survey will be available in the members-only area of this site later in February.
ESOP Company Boards Moving Toward Independent DirectorsOne of the more notable trends in ESOPs over the last several years has been the move to more outside, independent directors. According to a 2009 NCEO governance survey, the average board of directors has 5.6 members, of whom 61% are insiders, 27% are independent directors, and 12% are "affiliated directors." Twenty-six percent of boards are composed solely of insiders. Majority ESOP-owned companies are more likely to have independent directors. Companies in the 2009 survey were more likely to have independent directors than companies in the 2005 survey.
The median annual compensation for nonemployee directors is $10,000, excluding the 26% of companies that have uncompensated nonemployee directors. The vast majority of directors who are employees are not compensated specifically for their board service. Twenty-nine percent of companies provide a full pass-through of voting rights, and 17% have participants vote for some or all directors.
Survey results are available to NCEO members by contacting Loren Rodgers at email@example.com. The NCEO publishes a book on issues for board members, The ESOP Company Board Handbook. We can also direct members to other ESOP companies in their area who might have people interested in serving on boards and have a limited number of names of ESOP experts who also have an interest. Contact me at firstname.lastname@example.org for details.
Indian Companies Cutting Back on Broad-Based EquityOptions and other kinds of equity plans have been very common in the Indian technology sector. A number of other companies offer the plans as well, but not as commonly. Over the years, the number of companies granting equity awards broadly has moved up and down fairly dramatically. In the past few years, taxation of equity compensation in India has been in flux. In a new survey from ESOP Direct in India of 108 companies, the percentage of companies granting equity dropped from one-half to one-quarter. (Employee stock option plans are commonly abbreviated as ESOPs in India.) Eighty-four percent of the companies grant more than 50% of the options to senior management. Of these 30% companies grant options to only senior management. Information on obtaining the full survey is available at this link on ESOP Direct's site.
Ten Days Left to Apply for the Innovations AwardThe Innovations Award recognizes creative ideas in the employee ownership community. Learn more and fill out a brief application by February 10. Your company will get publicity, a free annual conference registration, and a chance to share your winning ideas with other companies.
Author biography and other columns in this series